Paper review
Paper ID:
Reviewer Recommendation Term: Definitely Accept() Probably accept()
Reject()
Overall Reviewer Manuscript Rating: Term Description Rating 1. Originality of Is the finding or approach original? Does the paper ideas / approach take into account relevant current and past research on the topic?(20) 2.rationality of Is the methodology or theory sufficiently sound, and methodology/ supported by the evidence? Is it testable? Is it solution preferable to competing theories?(30) 3.Experimental validation/conclusion 4.Quality writing 5. Language
Are thedata and analyses sound? Are the statistical design and analysis appropriate? Are there sufficient data to support the conclusion?(30) of Is the paper clear, logical, and understandable?Is the text flawless in detail (no mistaken formulas, wrong data,etc.)?( 10 ) Is the text linguistically and grammatically correct?( 10 ) Comments:
Please add any comments for the paper.