英语辩论赛评分细则
Adjudication will be based on the awards of marks in three categories: Matter (40%), Manner (40%) and Method(20%), for individual speeches and a team?s response to the dynamics of the debate.
按论据（40％）辩论风格（40％）采用的方式（20％）评判。
I. Matter relates to the issues in debate, the case being presented and the material used to substantiate argumentation. “Matter”指辩论过程中的论据，即用来支持论证的材料。
II. Manner refers to the presentation and delivery style of a speaker. The following list represents some of the elements which are, or may be, subsumed under Manner.
a) Vocal Style : Volume, clarity, pronunciation, pace, intonation, fluency, confidence, and authority. b)Language : Conversational.
c)Use of notes : Should not distract, should not be read d)Eye Contact : With audience. e)Gesture : Natural, appropriate. f)Stance : “ “
g)Dress : (only an issue if really inappropriate to the place or occasion). h)Sincerity : Believability
i)Personal Attacks : (derogatory comments are not to be tolerated). j)Humor : Effectiveness of ... appropriateness.
说话方式：音量，清晰度，发音，节奏，语调，是否流畅，自信心以及发言是否由份量。 语言：口语化得表达 提示条的使用：不得参照 和观众有目光接触 手势：自然，适当 站姿 着装：
真诚：要有可信度
不得使用贬低性的言语进行个人攻击。 幽默感：幽默要有效，适度 III. Method.
There are three major elements in the context of debating Method. These are:
a. Individual Method (speech).
b. Team Method (Case structure and organization).
c. Response to the dynamics of the debate (POI's, interjections and the effectiveness, currency and relevance of rebuttals)
1
辩论中的回应(如POI,质疑，反驳等等).
每位选手在辩论过程中必须至少回应一个point of information
Individual Method pertains to the structure and organization of an individual speech. This may be evident in a reasonably clear outline of the responsibilities of the speaker and the order of the issues to be dealt with in his/her speech. It may also be apparent in the degree of fluency with which a speech moves from one point to another in a clearly logical sequence.
Individual Method pertains to the ‘balance’ of a speech. Whereby, an equable division of speaking time is made to allow each of the phases of the speech a reasonable time for development (opening remarks, rebuttal, own points, summary, etc).
个人发言要注意提出论据的主次顺序，观点与观点之间的衔接是否自然，发言要“平衡”，每条论据给出相对均衡的时间，而且发言要掌握好时间限度。
Team Method pertains to the effectiveness of the team?s case organization and structure as a whole.
Team Method pertains to the equable division of roles (speakers) and responsibilities during a debate and the effective acquittal of those roles and responsibilities.
辩手在组内分工要明确，要各司其职。
Response to the dynamics of the debate pertains to the reactive abilities of speakers and teams to the ongoing strategies being employed by both sides, and the shifts in the balance of power from one side to another.
Teams and speakers should respond to clear strategic issues, not minor ?slips of the tongue? or insignificant points. 要针对要点，不要针对细枝末节辩论。 An ‘average’ speech shall be awarded: 平均水平的发言的分数一般如下: Matter : 30/40 Manner : 30/40 Method : 15/20 Total: 75/100 论据：30/40 辩论风格：30/40 采用方式：15/20
总分：75/100
高英教研组
2007年10月
2
Round One
Affirmative Matter 40% Matter 40% Matter 40% Matter 40% Matter 40% Matter 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Method 20% Method 20% Method 20% Method 20% Method 20% Method 20% Total 100 Total 100 Total 100 Total 100 Total 100 Total 100 Negative Debater Number 1 Debater Number 2 Debater Number 3 Debater Number 4 3
Round Two
Affirmative Matter 40% Matter 40% Matter 40% Matter 40% Matter 40% Matter 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Method 20% Method 20% Method 20% Method 20% Method 20% Method 20% Total 100 Total 100 Total 100 Total 100 Total 100 Total 100 Negative Debater Number 5 Debater Number 6 Debater Number 7 Debater Number 8
4
Final
Affirmative Matter 40% Matter 40% Matter 40% Matter 40% Matter 40% Matter 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Manner 40% Method 20% Method 20% Method 20% Method 20% Method 20% Method 20% Total 100 Total 100 Total 100 Total 100 Total 100 Total 100 Negative Debater Number Debater Number Debater Number Debater Number 5