A.C.Aranakeetal./RenewableEnergy75(2015)818e832831
greatlyreducedalthoughtherearestilllargeseparationregionsontheleewardsurfaceneartheleadingandtrailingedges.Byincreasinglfurther,inFig.20(c)and(d),separationiseliminatedexceptforthethinlaminarseparationbubblescuttingacrossthespanoftheblades.
Next,thepro ledragonashroudedturbineincreaseswithincreasingtipspeedratio.Neglectingthree-dimensionaleffects,thedragonasectionofaturbinebladeisgivenby
" 2
#d¼C1drðurÞ22þU∞¼C1Ulrdr2
∞þ1:
(5)
Thus,pro ledragisproportionaltol2andcanbeexpectedto
growsigni cantlyaslincreases.
Finally,themass owampli cationoftheshroudisalsoaffectedbyanincreaseinl.Asthetipspeedratioofawindturbinein-creases,thedistancesbetweensuccessivepassesofthetipvortexinthewakedecrease.Forashroudedturbine,thismeansthatmoreturnsofthewakearepresentintheshroudinterior.ThiscanbeseeninFig.21,whichplotsthemagnitudeofvorticityneartheshroudsurfaceinthevicinityoftheturbineblade.Increasingthetipspeedratiodrawswakevorticesclosertotheleadingedgeoftheshroudairfoilandincreasesthenumberoftimesthewakeinteractswiththeshroudboundarylayer.
TheimpactoftheincreasedinteractionbetweentheturbinewakeandtheshroudisexaminedinFig.22,whichshowsthepressuredistributionalongtheshroudforeachtipspeedratioconsidered.(ThelocationoftheazimuthalstationsintheseplotsisshowninFig.18(c)).TheareainsidethecurverepresentingthemeanCpdistributionmeasurestheliftforceontheshroudandisanindicatorofshroudperformance.Thisareadecreaseswithincreasingl,indicatingthattheimpactofthewakeistoreducetheperformanceoftheshroudasa owaccelerator.Indeed,exami-nationofvelocitypro les(notshown)forthesecasesrevealsthattheamountofaccelerationachievedbytheshroudattheturbineplanedecreaseswithincreasingl.
Atthehighesttipspeedratioconsidered,inFig.22(c),anespeciallyintensesuctionpeakappearsinthevicinityoftheblade(q¼0 ).However,themeansuctionislowerforthiscasethananyother.Thissigni esthepresenceofstrongpressuregradientsintheazimuthaldirectioninthiscase,andtheimpactofthishighsuctionpeakistosetthe owswirlingratherthandraw owaxiallythroughtheshroud.
Ofthethreephenomenadiscussedabove,theextentof owseparationoutweighstheothertwoinimportanceuptothepointwherethe owisfullyattachedontheblade.Beyondthispoint,increasinglfurtheronlyincreasesthepro ledragandreducestheshroudef ciency.
7.Conclusionsandfuturework
Theperformanceand ow eldofashroudedwindturbinehasbeencomputedandanalyzedindetail.High-liftairfoilshapesareconsideredforshroudgeometry.ValidationhasbeenperformedfortheRANSbasedmodelusedforcomputations,andtheuseofatransitionmodelisfoundtoimprovetheaccuracyofresults.
Aninvestigationofairfoilsectionsforshroudsofshroudedwindturbineshasbeenperformed.Ofanumberofairfoilshapesconsideredforshroudcrosssectionalpro les,theSeligS1223at-tainsthegreatestampli cationofmass ow.Three-dimensionalanalysisoffullshroudedturbinesystemsverifythebene tofincreasedmass owthroughtheplaneoftheturbine.Powerextractionupto90%beyondtheBetzlimitisachieved.Theimprovementinpowerextractionbeyondthebareturbineissub-stantial;theNACA0006shroudimprovespoweroverthebare
turbinebyafactorof1.93andtheS1223improvesitbyafactorof3.39atU∞¼5m/s.Theseresultsfurthersupporttheutilityoftheshroudedwindturbineasadevicethatcanbeusedeffectivelyatlowcut-inspeedsandofferpromisetosubstantiallyimprovetheenergycapturewhencomparedtoconventionalwindturbines.
Basedontheprecedinganalysis,thefollowingconclusionsaredrawnregardingthedesignofashroudedturbine:
Intheabsenceofaturbine,mass owampli cationthroughashroudincreasesapproximatelylinearlywithradialforce,andnonlinearbehavioroccursasthestagnationpointmovesfromtheinteriortotheexteriorsideoftheshroud.
Thewakeofashroudedturbineexpandsmorerapidlythananopenturbineandcanbetailoredtopromotemaximumpowerextraction.
Transitionhasanimportanteffectonthebehaviorofashroudedwindturbineandshouldbeaccountedforinanalysiswheneverfeasible.
Theshroudedturbinesystem'sperformanceismaximumataparticulartipspeedratio.Increasingthetipspeedratiobeyondthisoptimalvalueleadstolossesduetoseparation.
Theaboveconsiderationsprovideinsightforboththeanalysisanddesignofboththeshroudandtheturbineofashroudedtur-bine.Futureworkwillemployanoptimizationstrategytodesignashroudedturbinewithacontinueddetailedfocuson uidphysics.Thisprocedurewillincludearedesignofthetwist,chord,andthicknessdistributionoftheblade.Additionally,theresultspre-sentedhereshallbecomparedtolower-ordertheories,suchasthecommonly-usedactuatordiskmodel.Itwillalsobeinterestingtoconsidertheeffectofextremeloadsonsuchasystem,suchasahigh-speedgustatahighangleofattack.Acknowledgment
ThisworkissupportedbytheDoDNDSEGfellowshipandbytheDoEASCRprogramonFluid/StructureinteractionsinWindTurbineApplicationsatStanfordUniversity.References
[1]JamiesonP.BeatingBetz:energyextractionlimitsinaconstrained ow eld.
JSolEnergyEng2009;131.
[2]vanBusselG.Thescienceofmakingmoretorquefromwind:diffuserex-perimentsandtheoryrevisited.JPhysConfSer2007;75.
[3]LilleyGM,RainbirdWJ.Apreliminaryreportonthedesignandperformance
ofaductedwindmill.Report102.CollegeofAeronautics;1956.
[4]GilbertBL,ForemanKM.Experimentswithadiffuser-augmentedmodelwind
turbine.JEnergyResourTechnol1983;105.
[5]IgraO.Researchanddevelopmentforshroudedwindturbines.EnergyCon-servManag1981;21:13e48.
[6]HansenMOL,SørensenNN,FlayRGJ.Effectofplacingadiffuseraroundawind
turbine.WindEnergy2000;3.
[7]AbeK,OhyaY.Aninvestigationof ow eldsaround angeddiffusersusing
CFD.JWindEngIndAerodyn2004;92.
[8]AbeK,NishidaM,SakuraiA,OhyaY,KiharaH,WadaE,etal.Experimentaland
numericalinvestigationsof ow eldsbehindasmallwindturbinewitha angeddiffuser.JWindEngIndAerodyn2005;93(12):951e70.
[9]OhyaY,KarasudaniT,SakuraiA,AbeK-i,InoueM.Developmentofashrouded
windturbinewitha angeddiffuser.JWindEngIndAerodyn2008;96(5):524e39.
[10]OhyaY,KarasudaniT.Ashroudedwindturbinegeneratinghighoutputpower
withwind-lenstechnology.Energies2010;131.
[11]WerleMJ,PreszJrWM.Ductedwind/waterturbinesandpropellersrevisited.
JPropulsPower2008;24(5).
[12]BaederJ,DuraisamyK,LakshminarayanV.RANSpredictionsofcomplex
hoveringrotorcon gurations:putFluidDynJ2011;18(3e4).
[13]DuraisamyK,RamasamyM,BaederJ,LeishmanG.Highresolutionwake
capturingmethodologyforhoveringrotorsimulations.JAmHelicopterSoc2007;52(2).