A.C.Aranakeetal./RenewableEnergy75(2015)818e832819
recentlypublishedbyvanBussel[2].Theideaofashroudedturbinewas rstproposedbyLilleyandRainbird[3].Experimentalin-vestigationswereperformedinthe1980sbyGilbertandForeman[4]andbyIgra[5].AlthoughtheseexperimentsdiddemonstratethatpowerextractionbeyondtheclassicBetzlimitispossible,theshroudedturbinewasdeterminednottobepro tablecomparedtotraditionalwindturbinesandwasnotpursuedextensively.
Recentlyhowever,anincreaseinnumberofpublicationsonthetopicandattemptstocommercializetheideaindicatearenewedinterestinshroudedturbines.Researchershavecometoanagreementthatthereissigni cantpotentialforimprovementsinthisconceptandunderstandingthedetailsof owphysicsisoneofkeystoachievingthis.AninvestigationbyHansen[6]demonstratesusingbothlow- delitymomentumtheoryandCFDthatthepoweraugmentationofashroudedturbineisproportionaltotheincreaseinmass owratethroughtheturbineblades.Throughoutthepastdecade,theresearchgroupofOhya[7e10]haveperformedextensiveexperimentalandcomputationalworkonthistopicwhichhasledtothedevelopmentofahighperformanceso-called“ angeddiffuser”.
Duetothehighcostassociatedwithexperiments,computa-tionalstudiesareimportantforanin-depthunderstandingofthe owphysicsofshroudedturbines.However,totheauthorsknowledge,allthepreviousworkemploymodelingsimpli cationsthataffecttheaccuracyof ow eldpredictions.Earlywork[5,4]attemptedtomodelthebehaviorofashroudedwindturbineasaninternal owproblem,inwhichaturbinewasplacedinsideaductwithanimposedpressureconditionattheductoutlet.Morerecently,however,ithasbeendetermined[11,1]thatthisassump-tionisinaccurate,andamoreappropriateboundaryconditionisonewhichisimposedfardownstreamoftheentiresystem,i.e.,theshroudedturbinemustbetreatedasanexternal owproblem.
Insomeoftherecentcomputationalstudiesofshroudedtur-bines[6,7],anactuatordiskassumptionisusedtomodelthetur-bineblades.Insuchamodel,therotorisreplacedbyanin nitelythindiskacrosswhichapressuredropisexplicitlyimposed.Thissimpli cationoffersasubstantialcostsavingoverafullthree-dimensionalsolution,makingitausefultoolduringthepre-liminarydesignstage.Itdoesnot,however,capture nerandpotentionallyprofoundaspectsofthe owphysicsnearthebladeandinthewakeofashroudedturbine.Inaddition,theactuatordiskmodelcannotpredicttheeffectoftheturbinewakeon owsepa-rationalongthewallsoftheshroud.Thiseffect,the“swirlmixing
mechanism”mentionedinpreviousliterature[4],haspotentiallysigni cantconsequencesontheperformanceofashroudedturbine.
AfullyReynolds-Averaged-NaviereStokes(RANS)-basedCFDsimulationcanovercometheabovementionedmodelingissues.ThecurrentworkusesacompressibleRANSsolvertosimulateshroudedwindturbines.ThesolverhasbeenvalidatedpreviouslybyBaeder[12],Duraisamy[13,14]andLakshminarayan[15,16]foravarietyof owsincludingsingle,coaxial,andshroudedrotors,primarilyinthecontextofhelicopters.Whilethislegacyadmitsconsiderablecon denceintheaccuracyofthesolverforrotating ows,thesimulationofwindturbinespresentsanadditionalcomplication.Thisisduetofreetransitionfromlaminartoturbu-lent ow,whichoccursonwindturbinebladesduringtypicaloperatingconditionsandisfoundtosigni cantlyimpactbothpressureandviscousforces.Recently,authorsofthepresentworkhaveperformedadetailedvalidationof3Dsimulationsofanopenwindturbine[17]usingthegÀqtÀSAtransitionmodel[18],whichisdemonstratedtoaccuratelypredicttransitional owsintwoandthreedimensions.Apreliminaryinvestigationofshroudedturbineshasalsobeenperformedbypresentauthors[19].Theprimaryobjectiveofthepresentworkistoemploythispreviouslyvalidatedmethodologytoexaminetheperformanceand ow eldofshroudedwindturbines.
Theremainderofthispaperisorganizedasfollows.Section2outlinesthemethodologyemployedbythe owsolverOVER-TURNSwhichisusedthroughoutthiswork.InSection3,asum-maryofthevalidationispresented.InSection4,resultsarepresentedforabaselineshroudgeneratedfromaNACA0006airfoil.InSection5,axisymmetriccomputationsareperformedtoinves-tigateanumberofdifferentshroudgeometries.Basedonthisanalysis,thehigh-liftS1223airfoilshapeisselectedfordetailedinvestigation.InSection6,ashroudgeneratedfromaS1223airfoilsectionisexaminedindetail.Thebehavioroftheshroudedturbinewithvaryingtipspeedratioisinvestigated.Section7summarizesthekeyconclusionsandproposesfuturework.2.Methodology
Inthiswork,computationsareperformedusingtheoversetstructuredmeshsolverOVERTURNS[15].ThiscodesolvesthecompressibleRANSequationsusingapreconditioneddual-timeschemeinthediagonalizedapproximatefactorizationframework,describedbyBuelowetal.[20]andPandyaetal.[21].Inthisframework,timeisadvancedusingtheimplicitapproximatefactorizationmethoddevelopedbyPulliamandChaussee[22].LowMachpreconditioning,basedonthatdevelopedbyTurkel[23],isusedtoimprovebothconvergencepropertiesandtheaccuracyofthespatialdiscretization.InviscidtermsarecomputedusingathirdorderMUSCLschemeusingKoren'slimiterwithRoe's uxdiffer-encesplitting,andtheviscoustermsarecomputedusingsecondordercentraldifferencing.ForRANSclosure,theSpalarteAllmaras[24]turbulencemodelisemployed.Tocapturetheeffectsof owtransition,thegÀqtÀSA[18]modelisused.Thegoverningequationsaresolvedintherotatingframe,withno-slipconditionsaccountingforwallvelocitiesappliedonthesurfacesofboththeshroudandturbineblade.Animplicithole-cuttingtechniquedevelopedbyLee[25]andimprovedbyLakshminarayan[15]isusedtodeterminetheconnectivityinformationbetweenvariousoverlappingmeshes.
3.Assessmentoftransitionmodel
Inthissection,theperformanceofanewlyimplementedtran-sitionmodeliscarefullyevaluated.First,aperformance
prediction