A.C.Aranakeetal./RenewableEnergy75(2015)818e832821
Fig.3.Pressurecoef cientdistributionforS809
airfoil.
intensityofbelow0.5%.Theturbineisa2-bladedcon gurationwitharadiusofR¼5.029m.ThetipMachnumberisMtip¼0.1135andtherotationalvelocityisu¼72rpm.Aspreviouslymentioned,theS809airfoilisusedforthebladecrosssections.MeasurementsofperformanceandsurfacepressurearetakenforwindspeedsrangingfromU∞¼3m/sto25m/s.
Inthiswork,theturbinebladeisrepresentedbyaCeOmeshwithdimensions257Â51Â51inthewrap-around,spanwise,andnormaldirectionsrespectively.AviewofthemeshnearthebladetipispresentedinFig.5(a).Thismeshisembeddedinabackgroundmeshwithdimensions201Â133Â164intheazimuthal,radial,andaxialdirectionsrespectively.Thebackgroundmeshissemi-cylindrical,andperiodicboundaryconditionsareappliedonlateralfacestosimulateafulltwo-bladedrotor.The uiddomainextends2Rupstreamand6.8Rdownstreamand3.4Rlaterally.Theazimuthalgridspacingstretchestogive neresolutionina15 patchinthevicinityoftheturbineblade.Characteristicboundaryconditionsareusedforthein ow,out ow,andfar eldfaces.Awallboundaryconditionimposesno-sliponthebladeintherotatingframe.Thesingularityattheaxisisavoidedbybeginningtheradialpointdistributionatasmallvalueofr¼0.03.Anextrapolationboundaryconditionisappliedatthislocation.ThebackgroundmeshandboundaryconditionsaredepictedinFig.5(b).Toevaluate
gridconvergence,a nermeshwithdimensions257Â201Â101forthebladeand180Â264Â228forthebackgroundmesh(withuniformazimuthalspacing)wererunforonewindspeed,andtheintegratedloadsandpressurecoef cientswereallfoundtodifferbylessthan3%.Sincethemeshsizeisalreadyveryhigh,wedidnotperformmoreextensivere nementstudies.However,allofthesemeshesweregeneratedusingpriorexperienceindealingwithanumberofhighlysimilarproblemswiththesamecodeoverthepast15years[12e16].
Fig.6(a)plotsthecomputedtorqueoftheopenturbineatvariouswindspeeds.Thesecomputationswereperformedby rstattemptingasteady-statesolution,whichingeneraldidnotconverge,andthenusingtheobtainedresulttorestartatime-accuratesolution.Errorbarsshowtheminandmaxvaluesattained.Forcomparison,computationalresultsfromPotsdametal.[28]arealsoincluded.Atlowspeedswherethe owremainsattached,computationalresultsagreequitewellwithmeasureddata.Atthesespeeds,transitionplaysasmallroleinthebehaviorofthe ow,andthetransitionmodelhaslittleeffectontheintegratedresults.AvisualizationofthewakefromonesuchresultisshowninFig.6(b),whichplotsisocontoursofq-criterion[29].Thehelicalwakevortexpersistsforseveralturnswithminimalnumericaldiffusion.Asthefreestreamvelocityincreases,transitionplaysamoresigni cantroleinthe ow.PressuredistributionsattwospanwisestationsareshowninFig.6(c)and(d)forawindspeedofU∞¼10m/s.Thetransitionmodelisseentocapturethepressuredistributionmoreaccuratelythanthefullyturbulentassumptionattheselocations.AtspeedsbeyondU∞¼10m/s,the owisdeeplystalledovermuchoftheturbineblade,leadingtoaninherentlyunsteady owforwhichRANSbasedcalculationsareinsuf cient.Indeed,undersuchconditions,interactionbetweenthebladesandtowerplaysasigni cantroleinthebladeloading,andthetowersurfacemustbeincludedincalculationstoproducereasonableresults[30].
4.Baseline(NACA0006)shroud
Aninitialassessmentoftheshroudedturbineconceptisper-formedbyenclosingtheNRELVIbladeinasimpleshroud.Thisshroud,referredtoas“baseline,”isgeneratedbyextrudingaNACA0006airfoilsectionatanangleofattackintoanannularwing.Thebladegridandbackgroundgridarethesameasthoseusedforvalidation.Thedimensionsfortheshroudgridare267Â201Â49inthewrap-around,spanwise,andnormaldirectionsrespectively.Fig.7(a)showssectionsofthebladeandshroudgrids,andFig.7
(b)
Fig.4.TransitionlocationsforS809airfoil.Thesquaresymbolsinthisplotareexperimentaldatapoints.ErrorbarsshowthesizeoftheseparationbubbleintheCFDsolution.