LEXICAL QUALITY
Underlyingefficientprocessesareknowledgecomponents;knowledgeaboutwordforms(grammaticalclass,spellingsandpronunciations)andmeanings.Addeffectivepractice(readingexperience)oftheseknowledgecomponents,andtheresultisefficiency:therapid,low-resourceretrievalofawordidentity.Lexicalquality(LQ)referstotheextenttowhichthereader’sknowledgeofagivenwordrepresentstheword’sformandmeaningconstituentsandknowledgeofwordusethatcombinesmeaningwithpragmaticfeatures.Thusthevocabularyofagivenlanguageincludes,foragivenreader,wordsofwidelyvaryingLQ,fromrarewordsneverencounteredtofrequentlyencounteredandwell-knownwords.Like-wise,individualreadersdifferintheaverageLQoftheirwords.Thisreadervari-abilityisnotjustaboutthesizeofvocabulary,althoughitincludesthis;itisabouttherepresentationofwords,thestableandlessstableknowledgethereaderhasabout the word’s form and meaning.
Ofcourse,thequestionbecomeswhatis“quality,”awordthatcouldevokesus-picionwithoutsomedefinition.Qualityistheextenttowhichamentalrepresenta-tionofawordspecifiesitsformandmeaningcomponentsinawaythatisbothpre-ciseandflexible.Theprecisionisneededbecause“prettyandpetty”and“knightandnight”arenotthesame.Theflexibilityisneededbecausethemeaningsof“roamingcharge”and“afeechargedbyamobilephoneserviceforcallsinitiatedorreceivedoutsideacontractedservicearea”arethesame.Bothprecisionandflexibilityareneededtounderstandandpronouncerecordin“Youneedarecordofthetransaction”and“Theycan’trecordtheconversation.”Thesesimpleexamplesarejustthetipoftheicebergofform-meaningcomplexities.LQprovidesameansforsafepassagethroughthem.Earlierchapters(Perfetti&Hart,2001,2002)con-tain additional examples and theoretical discussions of LQ.
OnewaytobecomemorespecificaboutLQistoidentifythefeaturesthatwehy-pothesizetodistinguishhigherqualityfromlowerqualityrepresentations.Table1doesthis.Itidentifiesfivefeaturesoflexicalrepresentationthatdistinguishhighandlowqualityandshowsthree(theremaybemore)hypothesizedconsequencesof
360PERFETTI
TABLE 1
Properties and Consequences of Lexical Quality
Representational Properties
of Lexicon
Orthography
PhonologyHigh QualityFully specified; letters areconstantsRedundant word-specific
phonology and context-
sensitive grapheme-phoneme
phonology
All grammatical classes of the
word represented; morpho-
syntactic inflections
represented
More generalized, less
context-bound; fuller range
of meaning dimensions to
discriminate among words in
same semantic field.
Orthographic, phonological, and
semantic constituents are
tightly boundLow QualityNot fully specified; some lettersare variablesLess stable because of variableword-specific phonology and/or grapheme-phonemephonologyIncomplete range of form classuses; less stablemorpho-syntaxMore context bound; fewerrelevant meaning dimensionsto discriminate among relatedwordsOrthographic, phonological, andsemantic constituents are lesstightly boundGrammarMeaningConstituent binding
Possibleprocessingconsequences
duringreading
StabilityHigher; word identity is reliably
retrieved from an
orthographic or phonological
input
SynchronicityWord identity constituents are
activated and retrieved in
synchrony as a word identity
Meaning integrationHigher; word identities
available for building
comprehensionLower; word identity issometimes not retrieved froman orthographic orphonological inputWord constituents may beactivated and retrievedasynchronously; (e.g. laboreddecoding; activation ofincorrect meanings frompartial input)Lower; comprehensionprocesses that operate overword identities at risk
thesequalityfeaturesforreadingprocesses.Therepresentationalfeaturesarethefourconstituentsofwordidentity—orthography,phonology,morpho-syntax,andmeaning.Thefifthrepresentationfeatureisconstituentbinding,thedegreetowhichthefirstfourfeaturesareboundtogether(especiallythefirstthree;thegrammaticalfeaturemightbeconsideredtobeimplementedbyagrammaticalprocessthatoper-atesonthelexeme).Bindingsareconnectionsthatsecurecoherenceamongthecon-stituents,theorthographic,phonological,andsemanticrepresentations,whichto-getheraretheword’sidentity.Thebindingfeatureisnotindependentbutrathera
LEXICAL QUALITY361
consequenceoftheorthographic,phonologicalandsemanticconstituentsbecomingwellspecifiedinassociationwithanotherconstituent.
TheconsequencesofhighqualityinsublexicalandlexicalknowledgearealsoshowninTable1.Thesearehypothesizedconsequencesthataresubjecttoempiri-caltesting,andsomehaveatleastindirectevidence.Forexample,thehypothesisthatlowLQcanleadtotheasynchronousactivationofwordconstituentsisconsis-tentwithresultsofBreznitzandMisra(2003),whofoundthatERPindicatorsoforthographyandphonologyforlow-skillreadingweremoreasynchronousthanthoseofskilledreaders.Moregenerally,readingwordsincontextisaffectedbyLQ,providingtheimportanthypothesizedlinkbetweenLQandcomprehension(Perfetti&Hart,2001).ThegeneraldescriptionofthislinkisthatlocalprocessesofintegratingwordmeaningswithinandacrosssentenceboundariesareaffectedbytheLQofwordsthatareidentifiedaspartofthecomprehensionprocess.Onefi-nalobservationconcernsthedifferencebetweenaspokenandwrittenword.Myfocusisonreading,andforthatorthographyispartofLQ.However,alexicalanal-ysiscanbeappliedtojustspokenlanguagewithafocusonphonologicalrepresen-tations and meaning.