366
PERFETTI
trainandthentestwereunknown,theto-be-learnedwordswereindividuallytai-loredforeachparticipantaccordingtothepretest.Followingsimpleassociationinstruction(50mininwhichtherarewordswerepairedwithbriefdefinition-likeparaphrases),thetrainedwords,untrainedrarewords,andfamiliarwordswerepresentedformeaningjudgments.Inthemeaningjudgmenttask,thefirstwordap-pearedfor1secandthendisappeared,replacedbythesecondwordthatwasre-latedinmeaningon50%oftrials.Forexample,gloamingfollowedbytwilight,shouldgetayesresponse.EEGswererecordedcontinuouslyduringthesejudg-ments,soweobtainedERPindicatorsassociatedwithviewingthefirstword(gloaming) and its meaning mate (twilight).
Figure2showsthebehavioralresultsobtainedduringtheposttrainingmeaningjudgmentstask.Thethingtonoticeisthatskilledcomprehenderswerecorrectsig-nificantlymoreoftenthanlessskilledcomprehendersinmeaningjudgmentsmadetotherarewordsthatwetaughtthembutnottoeitheruntrainedrarewordsorfa-miliarwords(alsonottrained).Thelackofaskilldifferenceforuntrainedrarewordsshowsthatoverallknowledgeofrarewordswasnotdifferentacrossthetwogroups.Instead,theconclusionisthatthehighercomprehendersactuallylearnedthe new words better.
TheresultsoftheERPanalysis,whichareshowninFigure3forthegroupofskilledcomprehenders,addtothispicture.Plottedarethegrandaveragewave-formsatoneelectrode(thecentralreferenceelectrode)foreachconditionformeaning-relatedtrials.Theconditionsshowasimilarpatternforthefirst200msecorso,reflectingvisualorthographicprocessessharedbyallwords.Thefirstpointofseparationoccursat200msec,wheretrainedwordsseparatefrombothun-trainedandfamiliarwordsinanegativegoingshift.Thisreflectsanearly“notice”FIGURE2Comprehensionskilldifferencesinwordmeaningjudgmentsfollowinglearningofrarewords.Skilledcomprehendersshowedhigheraccuracyinjudgingmeaningrelationsfortrainedrarewordsbutnotforuntrainedrarewordsorfamiliar(known)words.BasedonPerfetti, Wlotko, and Hart (2005).
LEXICAL QUALITY
367
FIGURE3Anevent-relatedpotential(ERP)recordforskilledcomprehendersduringameaningjudgment.Thegrandaveragewaveformisshownforthereferenceelectrode(Cz).Theonsetofthefirstwordisexemplifiedforthetrainedrarewordgloaming.Theonsetofthesecondwordisexemplifiedfortherelatedwordtwilight.ThethreecurvesrepresentERPrecordsfortrainedrarewords(darkestline),untrainedfamiliar(known)words(intermediatedarkness),anduntrainedrarewords(lightestline).Twosignificanteffectsoftrainingarevisible,at200msecandabout550msec,thelatterrepresentingword-levelepisodicmemoryforthetrainedword.About400msecaftertheonsetofarelatedword,areductionintheN400isobservedfortrainedandfamiliarwords.Forthetrainedwords,lessskilledcomprehenders(notshown)showweakerepisodiceffectsat550msecandweakerN400meaningeffectsforthesecondrelatedword. See Perfetti, Wlotko, & Hart (2005)for fuller skill comparisons.
ofwordsthathadbeenrecentlyviewedintraining,basedonpreidentitysublexicalpatterns.Asecondseparationataround550msec,whichdoesmarkwordidentity,furtherdistinguishestrainedwordsfromtheothertwoclasses,nowinapositivegoingshift.Thisshiftisthesameinkeyrespects(distributionandpolarity)astheP600thatisobservedinmemorystudieswhenapreviouslyvieweditemispre-sented(Curran,1999;Rugg,1995).ThisERPshiftmarksrecognitionoftheepi-sodicmemorylaiddownbythetrainingevent:Ineffect,thebrainrespondstothiswordasfamiliarbecausethewordhasbeenpartoftheprevioushour’straining.Awordthathasgaineditsfamiliaritythroughexperiencespriortotheexperiment(thefamiliarwords)showsnosucheffect.Theimplicationofthisisthatwehaveidentifiedamarkeroffamiliarity-basedlearningthatisexpressedwhenareaderviews a word.
368PERFETTI
Sonowthequestioniswhetherthisword-levelepisodicmemoryeffectisob-servedequallyinourskilledandlessskilledcomprehenders.Theanswerisno.LessskilledreadersshowedthesameFigure3patternofERPshiftsduringthemeaningjudgments.However,thekeymarkerofepisodicmemoryat550msec(theP600trainingeffect)wassignificantlyreducedinamplitudeforthelessskilledcomprehenders.Thus,onaverage,awordthathadbeenlearnedjustpriortotheexperimentmadelessofanimpressiononthelessskilledreaders.Itisinterest-ingthatthefirsteffectoftraining,the200-msecnegativityfortrainedwords,wasnotdifferentforthetwoskillgroups.Ifourinterpretationofthesetwocomponentsiscorrect—thatthe200msecisbasedonsublexicalfamiliaritywhereasthe550-mseceffectisbasedonlexicalidentity—thenweconcludethatalllearnersre-spondtothedistinctiveletterpatternofarecentlytrainedword,buttheydifferinrecognizingthewordepisode—forexample,thisisthatwordgloamingthatIjustexperienced a few minutes ago.
Recognizinga“gloaming”word-episodemayinvolveretrievingitsmeaning,butitmaynot.Themoredirecttestofameaningprocessisintheresponsetothesecondword,twilight.Iftheparticipanthaslearnedthemeaningofgloaming,thenthesecondword,twilight,whichiscloselyrelatedinmeaning,shouldproduceareducedN400.TheN400isasignatureforsemanticcongruence,alargenegativegoingshiftwhenawordisincongruentwithitsprecedingcontext.Whenawordiscongruentwithitsprecedingcontext,theN400isreduced.ThisN400reductioniswhathappenedwhengloamingwasfollowedbytwilight—providedthemeaningofgloamingwaslearned.AsshowninFigure3,anN400appearedfortheun-trainedwords,reflectingthefactthatifaparticipanthadnotexperiencedgloamingintraining,therewasnoparticularcongruenceprovidedbythewordtwilight.However,ifgloaminghadbeenlearned,thentheN400shouldbereduced,andthisreduction, as well as one for familiar words, is visible in Figure 3.