374PERFETTI
TABLE 3
Summary Skill Pattern in Landi ERP Results
Comprehension
Skill Differences in
Decision Times?
Yes
Yes
Yes
YesComprehensionSkill Differencesin ERP Measures?NoNoYes, but small(P200, N400)Yes, large (P200,N400)TaskPhonological decisionsSemantic picture decisionsSemantic word decisions—CategoricalSemantic word decisions—Associative
Note.Source: Landi and Perfetti (2007). ERP = event-related potential.
Whereasthedecisionstimesshowedverygeneralprocessing-speeddiffer-ences,theERPmeasuresshoweddifferencesthatwererestrictedtothesemanticworddecisions,andtheseresultspresentaslightlydifferentpicture.BothgroupsshowedareliablereductionintheN400forrelatedtrialsforbothcategoryandas-sociativepairs,althoughineachcasethereductionshownbyskilledcompre-henderswassomewhatlarger.Moreover,thehigh-skillgroup,butnotthelow-skillgroup,showedanadditionalN400reductionfortheassociativelyrelatedpairsrel-ativetothecategorypairs.Thus,contrarytotheexpectationthatlessskilledcomprehenderswouldhavespecificproblemswithcategoryrelations,theERPssuggestthatsemanticcategoryprocesseswerecomparableinthetwogroups,buttheERPsforassociativerelationswerenot.(Thetendencyforlessskilledcom-prehenderstotakerelativelylongerthanskilledcomprehendersoncategorydeci-sionsmayberelevant;howeversuchadifferencecouldbeinterpretedasanaddi-tionalcheckingprocesswellbeyondthemoreautomaticsemanticprocessthatisreflected in the N400.)3
Table3showsasummaryofskilldifferencesacrosstasks.Takentogether,theysuggestdetailedevidenceforsemantic-processingdifferencesbetweentheskilledandlessskilledcomprehenders.TheERPevidencesuggestedthatskilledcom-prehendershadastrongermeaningcongruenceresponsewhenwordswerecate-goricallyrelated,andthisresponsewasevenstrongerwhenthewordswerealsoas-sociativelyrelated.Thelessskilledgroupshowedacongruenceresponsealso,butthisresponsewasnotstrengthenedbyassociativerelations.Noticethatifallwehadwerebehavioraldata,ourconclusionwouldbedifferent,andperhapsmislead-ing.Wewouldconcludethatthereisnosemanticprocessingskilldifference3TheERPresultsalsoproducedevidenceforearlysemanticeffectsat200msecthatweremorecon-sistentacrosselectrodesitesandtrialconditionsforskilledcomprehenders.Theyalsoshowed200-mseceffectsforthephonologicaltask,comparinghomophonesversusnonhomophonesthatwerecomparable across the two groups.
LEXICAL QUALITY375
specifictolanguage,becauseofdifferencesinpicturedecisionspeed.Andwewouldhaveconcludedthatthesegroupsdifferedeitheronphonologicalprocesses(becauseofthephonologicaldecisionspeeddifferences)or,morelikely,onnon-specificprocessing-speeddifferences.TheERPdataaretellingusmoredirectlyaboutthebrain’sresponsetowords,andtheyseemtosaythattherearespecificskill differences related to word-meaning processes.
Lexical Processing During Text Comprehension
Myfinalexamplereturnstothekeylinkbetweenlexicalprocessesandcompre-hension.Thislinkismostdirectatthelevelofshortrunsoftext,asentenceortwo,whereonecanobservewordprocessing“on-line”aspartoftextreading.Thefocalissueistheprocessesthatintegratethewordcurrentlybeingreadwiththeongoingrepresentationofthetext.Thisintegrationisacentralconnectingeventbetweenword identification and text comprehension.
Theskillquestioniswhetherdifferencesingloballyassessedcomprehensionariseatthislocal(i.e.,onewordatatime)processing.Doskilledcomprehendersintegratewordsimmediatelyintothetext?Dolessskilledcomprehenders?TheLQH(andalsoverbalefficiencytheory)predictsword-textintegrationproblemsfor less skilled readers.
Onceagain,ourstudiesonthisquestionuseERPstoexaminetheN400seman-ticcongruenceindicator.TheN400hasbeenfoundtovarywithdemandsonsen-tenceandtext-levelintegration(vanBerkum,Hagoort,&Brown,1999),anditisthatfactthatweexploitedintwoparallelstudies,onewithskilledcomprehenders(Yang,Perfetti,&Schmalhofer,2007)andonewithlessskilledcomprehenders(Yang,Perfetti,&Schmalhofer,2005).Theapproachofthestudiesisillustratedinthe following text:
Afterbeingdroppedfromtheplane,thebombhitthegroundandexploded.Thewas ….
ERPswereacquiredaseachwordwasread.Theunderlining(notvisibletopartici-pants) marks the target word (explosion) for our analysis.
Whenthereadercomestoexplosionatthebeginningofthesecondsentence,itshouldberelativelyeasytointegratethewordwithanunderstandingofthetextbasedonthefirstsentence.Thatis,wecanassumethatthereader’stextmemoryincludestheevent-proposition[bombexploded],amongotherpropositionsfromthefirstsentence,andthewordexplosionisintegratedwiththisevent-proposition;thatis,itistakenascoreferentialwiththeproposition.Thisconditionistermed“explicit” because there are explicit coreferential phrases (exploded, explosion).Asecondcondition,theparaphrasedcondition,wasofspecialinterestfromasemanticprocessingpointofview.Insteadofthefirstsentencereferringto